Virgin Hotels New York City
Best for skyline rooftop drinks, a seasonal pool scene, and a high-energy, modern Manhattan vibe.
Hotel comparison guide
Virgin Hotels New York City vs The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel
Virgin Hotels New York City is a contemporary, lively NoMad hotel with rooftop pools, multiple bars, and an Exhale Spa — best for travelers who want a social, modern Manhattan stay. The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel is an Upper East Side heritage luxury hotel known for Bemelman's Bar and a long run of celebrity guests — best for those seeking classic, discreet Fifth Avenue–adjacent service and old‑school elegance.
Updated · about 3.8 km apart
The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel
Best for traditional luxury, discreet service, and classic New York glamour near Central Park and museum row.
Quick Verdict: Virgin Hotels New York City vs The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel
When Virgin Hotels New York City wins: pick Virgin if you want a younger, buzzy property with multiple rooftop venues, a seasonal pool deck and an active nightlife program in NoMad.
When The Carlyle wins: choose The Carlyle if you prefer a quieter Upper East Side address, classic Art Deco elegance, and a hotel with strong name recognition, signature public rooms like Bemelman's Bar, and Rosewood-level luxury service.
Bottom line: both are five-star Manhattan options but serve different tastes — Virgin for contemporary social scenes and rooftop life, The Carlyle for a heritage luxury stay close to Central Park and museums.
Virgin Hotels New York City vs The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel – At a Glance
| Category | Virgin Hotels New York City | The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Contemporary, lively, social — modern design and nightlife focus | Upper East Side heritage luxury — classic, discreet, formal public rooms |
| Location | NoMad (1227 Broadway) — close to Empire State Building, Penn Station, Herald Square | Upper East Side (35 E 76th St) — near Central Park and the Metropolitan Museum of Art |
| Size (rooms) | About 460 Chambers and suites (38 floors) | 188 guestrooms |
| Ages / policy | All ages welcome; one guest must be 21+ to check in; Pool Club restricts 21+ after late morning | All ages welcome (not adults-only) |
| Pools | Seasonal fourth-floor rooftop pool deck with loungers, cabanas and a Pool Club bar | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Everdene (New American rooftop), El Cielo, The Riff Raff Club, The Pool Club — multiple rooftop venues | Two restaurants and Bemelman's Bar (famous hotel bar/lounge); 24-hour room service available |
| Spa & wellness | Exhale Spa with hammam, dry sauna, Snow Room, Salt Room, 10 treatment rooms; 24/7 fitness center | Full-service spa and fitness facilities (Rosewood property services) |
| Known for | Rooftop pool and bars, lively events and nightlife programming | Bemelman's Bar, celebrity history, heritage Art Deco service and location |
| Accessibility & services | Valet parking, concierge, destination fee covers Wi‑Fi & fitness access, extensive event spaces | Valet parking (surcharge), concierge, multilingual staff, business center, limo/town car service |
| Nearby highlights | Empire State Building, Madison Square Park, Penn Station, Herald Square | Central Park, Metropolitan Museum of Art, Madison Avenue shopping |
A Look Inside Virgin Hotels New York City
See all photos →
Location: NoMad energy vs Upper East Side calm
Virgin Hotels New York City – Location
Virgin sits at 1227 Broadway in NoMad, a short walk from the Empire State Building and Penn Station.
- Walkable to Herald Square, Macy’s and Madison Square Park.
- Good for subway and rail connections (Penn Station nearby).
- NoMad’s restaurants and nightlife are steps from the lobby.
Pick Virgin if you want immediate access to Midtown shopping, transit and a lively neighborhood.
The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel – Location
The Carlyle is at 35 E 76th St on the Upper East Side, minutes from Central Park and the Met.
- Short walk to museum row and Madison Avenue shops.
- Quieter, more residential streets and traditional luxury retail nearby.
- Easier access to Central Park walking routes than Manhattan midtown hotels.
Choose The Carlyle for a refined Upper East Side base close to Central Park and cultural attractions.
Rooms: modern Chambers vs heritage guestrooms
Virgin Hotels New York City – Rooms
Virgin’s roughly 460 Chambers and suites favor floor-to-ceiling windows and contemporary design.
- Room types include Room, City View; Chamber King; Sky Grand Chamber Suite configurations.
- Many rooms emphasize skyline views (Empire State/NoMad vistas).
- Suites include terrace and larger Sky Grand Chamber Suite options.
Virgin’s rooms are larger in number and oriented around modern, skyline-focused design.
The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel – Rooms
The Carlyle offers 188 guestrooms and a wide range of suites, from standard rooms to multi‑bedroom suites.
- Room types listed include Superior Room, Deluxe Room, Executive Room and multiple named suites (Suite (Carlyle), Premier Suite, Suite (Central Park)).
- Decor and layout reflect the hotel’s heritage and classic luxury styling.
- Accessible room options are available across several categories.
The Carlyle’s rooms prioritize classic luxury and a quieter, residential feel over modern rooftop views.
Dining & drinks: multiple rooftop venues vs classic bars
Virgin Hotels New York City – Dining & drinks
Virgin centers food and drink on rooftop venues and a mix of casual and fine options.
- Everdene is a rooftop New American restaurant with all-day service and a terrace.
- The Pool Club and The Riff Raff Club provide rooftop cocktails and skyline-focused drinking spots.
- El Cielo offers Colombian fine dining for a more intimate evening.
Virgin is suited to guests who want skyline dining and multiple on-site bar options in a single property.
The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel – Dining & drinks
The Carlyle is known for its classic public rooms and Bemelman's Bar alongside two restaurants and 24-hour room service.
- Bemelman's Bar is a signature, historically notable hotel bar.
- Two restaurants on-site provide traditional dining service and in‑room dining options.
- Service is oriented toward discreet, formal table service and private dining requests.
The Carlyle appeals to travelers seeking classic hotel dining rooms and a famed bar with history.
Pools & signature amenity: rooftop pool deck vs classic public rooms
Virgin Hotels New York City – Pools & signature amenity
Virgin’s seasonal fourth-floor rooftop pool deck is a major draw in warm months.
- Pool deck includes loungers, cabanas and Pool Club bar with Empire State Building views.
- Pool access open to all ages in mornings; Pool Club enforces 21+ after midday.
- Reservations and fees can apply for loungers/cabanas and non‑hotel guests.
Virgin’s pool is a social rooftop amenity best for warm-season stays and skyline lounging.
The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel – Pools & signature amenity
The Carlyle’s listing highlights its classic public spaces and a full-service spa as signature offerings.
- Bemelman's Bar and the hotel’s formal public rooms are central to its identity.
- The property offers a full-service spa for guest treatments.
- No on-site pool is published in the supplier listing.
The Carlyle’s signature is its historic public rooms and service rather than a rooftop pool scene.
Wellness & nightlife: Exhale spa and late-night bars vs discreet luxury service
Virgin Hotels New York City – Wellness & nightlife
Virgin combines a full Exhale Spa and a 24/7 fitness center with late-night rooftop bars.
- Exhale Spa offers hammam, dry sauna, Snow Room, Salt Room and multiple treatment rooms.
- Fitness Center open 24/7 with Technogym equipment; included in the Destination Fee.
- Nightlife leans into rooftop bars and programmed events (happy hour, live music).
Virgin is a better fit if you want a full spa plus active late-night rooftop venues on-site.
The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel – Wellness & nightlife
The Carlyle focuses on classic, low-key luxury, with a full-service spa and quiet evening bars.
- Spa and fitness facilities are provided as part of the hotel’s luxury offering.
- Nightlife is subdued and centered on historic bars and formal lounges rather than club-style venues.
- Service emphasizes discretion and traditional concierge support.
The Carlyle fits travelers who prefer understated evenings and traditional spa services.
Who Wins? Best Pick by Travel Style
Virgin Hotels New York City
Virgin Hotels New York City — seasonal rooftop pool deck, multiple rooftop bars and Empire State Building views.
The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel
The Carlyle — long-standing Upper East Side icon with Bemelman's Bar and Rosewood-level service.
Virgin Hotels New York City
Virgin — programmed happy hours, rooftop clubs and live-music access included in the hotel’s event calendar.
The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel
The Carlyle — a short walk to the Metropolitan Museum of Art and Central Park.
Frequently asked questions
See all FAQs →Virgin Hotels New York City vs The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel: FAQs
Which hotel is better for families with kids?
Both welcome families, but Virgin’s Pool Club restricts access to 21+ after midday, so families should plan pool time for mornings; The Carlyle is quieter and near Central Park for family outings.
Which hotel has the rooftop pool?
Virgin Hotels New York City has a seasonal rooftop pool deck; The Carlyle does not publish an on-site pool.
Which is more convenient for museums?
The Carlyle is closer to Central Park and the Metropolitan Museum of Art; Virgin is closer to Midtown landmarks like the Empire State Building and Penn Station.
How do the spas compare?
Virgin houses an Exhale Spa with specialized features (hammam, Snow Room, Salt Room and recovery passes); The Carlyle lists a full-service spa but fewer public detail points are published in the supplier listing.
More Virgin Hotels New York City Comparison Guides
Explore how Virgin Hotels New York City stacks up against other hotels nearby:
- Virgin Hotels New York City vs Waldorf Astoria New York
- Virgin Hotels New York City vs The St. Regis New York
- Virgin Hotels New York City vs Four Seasons Hotel New York
- Virgin Hotels New York City vs The Ritz-Carlton New York, Central Park
- Virgin Hotels New York City vs Mandarin Oriental, New York
- Virgin Hotels New York City vs Park Hyatt New York
- Virgin Hotels New York City vs The Pierre, A Taj Hotel, New York
- Virgin Hotels New York City vs Baccarat Hotel and Residences New York
- Virgin Hotels New York City vs The Ritz-Carlton New York, NoMad
- Virgin Hotels New York City vs The Langham, New York, Fifth Avenue
- Virgin Hotels New York City vs Lotte New York Palace
- Virgin Hotels New York City vs Trump International Hotel & Tower New York
- Virgin Hotels New York City vs JW Marriott Essex House New York
- Virgin Hotels New York City vs The New York EDITION
- Virgin Hotels New York City vs The Times Square EDITION
- Virgin Hotels New York City vs 1 Hotel Central Park
- Virgin Hotels New York City vs The Whitby Hotel
- Virgin Hotels New York City vs The Surrey A Corinthia Hotel
- All Virgin Hotels New York City comparisons
Book your stay
Rooftop Pool Access & Skyline Views
- Lowest rate guarantee
- Complimentary perks & upgrades
- 24/7 concierge