Virgin Hotels New York City
Best for skyline rooftop time, energetic bars, and a seasonal pool experience in NoMad.
Hotel comparison guide
Virgin Hotels New York City vs The New York EDITION
Virgin Hotels New York City is a playful luxury lifestyle hotel in NoMad with rooftop pool, multiple bars, and an on-site Exhale Spa — good for travelers who want skyline views and lively dining/drinking. The New York EDITION is a stylish, quieter five-star hotel beside Madison Square Park — aimed at guests who prefer refined design and a central Flatiron/Madison Square Park address.
Updated · about 0.8 km apart
The New York EDITION
Best for a quieter, design-forward luxury stay steps from Madison Square Park and the Flatiron District.
Quick Verdict: Virgin Hotels New York City vs The New York EDITION
When Virgin Hotels New York City wins: pick Virgin if you want rooftop pool access, multiple lively bars and restaurants, and a more playful, social hotel vibe — good for groups, nightlife, and skyline photo moments.
When The New York EDITION wins: choose The New York EDITION if you prefer a quieter, refined five-star hotel with a prime Madison Square Park / Flatiron location and a signature restaurant (The Clocktower) and fewer in-house party elements.
Bottom line: both are luxury lifestyle hotels within walking distance of each other; Virgin is the more active, rooftop-forward choice while The EDITION is the more reserved, classic luxury option.
Virgin Hotels New York City vs The New York EDITION – At a Glance
| Category | Virgin Hotels New York City | The New York EDITION |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Playful, social luxury with rooftop energy and bars | Stylish, restrained five-star lifestyle hotel |
| Location | NoMad, near Empire State Building, Penn Station and Madison Square Park | Beside Madison Square Park and the Flatiron Building |
| Size (guest rooms) | Approximately 460 Chambers and suites | 271 air-conditioned rooms |
| Building/Stories | 38-story tower | Not published |
| Pools | Seasonal fourth-floor rooftop pool deck with Pool Club (age restrictions apply midday) | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Everdene, El Cielo, The Riff Raff Club, The Pool Club — 2+ restaurants and multiple bars | The Clocktower (on-site restaurant) and 2 bars/lounges; 24-hour room service |
| Spa & wellness | Exhale Spa with hammam, dry sauna, snow room, salt room; 24/7 fitness center | Spa services on site, fitness facilities; specific spa amenities not fully listed |
| Meeting & event space | Extensive event spaces including The Loft and multiple rooftop venues (large capacities) | Conference space ~2,100 sq ft and 5 meeting rooms |
| Known for | Rooftop pool deck with Empire State Building views and lively bars | Stylish EDITION branding and location steps from Madison Square Park |
| Family / age policy | All ages welcome (21+ required to book/check in); pool access restricted to 21+ from midday | |
A Look Inside Virgin Hotels New York City
See all photos →
Location: NoMad energy vs Madison Square Park calm
Virgin Hotels New York City – Location
Virgin Hotels New York City sits in NoMad, within short walks of Penn Station, Herald Square, Macy’s and the Empire State Building.
- Address: 1227 Broadway, NoMad; close to 33rd Street transit and Penn Station.
- Walkable to Empire State Building (about a 5-minute walk) and Madison Square Garden.
- Good base for shopping and Midtown sightseeing; lively neighborhood nightlife.
Choose Virgin for a central, energetic NoMad location with easy transit access.
The New York EDITION – Location
The New York EDITION is positioned beside Madison Square Park and the Flatiron Building.
- Address: 5 Madison Avenue, steps from Madison Square Park and 5th Avenue.
- Short walk to the Flatiron Building and many Flatiron/NoMad restaurants.
- A quieter immediate setting compared with some Midtown blocks.
Pick The EDITION for a classy Flatiron / Madison Square Park address with easy access to downtown boutiques and cafés.
Rooms: Chambers & suites vs EDITION rooms
Virgin Hotels New York City – Rooms
Virgin's roughly 460 Chambers and suites focus on floor-to-ceiling city views and modern rooms.
- Room types include Room, Chamber King, Sky Chamber views, and several Grand Suite variations.
- Rooms offer floor-to-ceiling windows and skyline views; some suites include terraces.
- Free high-speed Wi‑Fi is included as part of the mandatory Destination Fee.
Virgin is a large-property choice with many room types and strong skyline views.
The New York EDITION – Rooms
The New York EDITION has 271 air‑conditioned rooms across traditional EDITION room types.
- Room type names include Room, Superior Room, Deluxe Room, Studio, Loft and Suites (many accessible room variants listed).
- Rooms have minibars, Smart TVs, pillowtop beds with down comforters, and complimentary wired and wireless internet.
- Some room listings explicitly note mobility- and hearing-accessible options.
The EDITION offers a concise, design-focused room set with several accessible options.
Dining & drinks: Multiple rooftop venues vs The Clocktower
Virgin Hotels New York City – Dining & drinks
Virgin's food-and-drink scene is varied and rooftop-forward, with Everdene and several bars.
- Everdene: New American indoor-outdoor rooftop restaurant serving breakfast, lunch and dinner (hours listed).
- The Riff Raff Club: 39th-floor cocktail lounge with skyline views and happy hour.
- El Cielo and The Pool Club add fine-dining and poolside casual options; multiple bars across the property.
Virgin suits guests who want a range of dining moods and rooftop drinks without leaving the hotel.
The New York EDITION – Dining & drinks
The New York EDITION centers dining around The Clocktower and two bars/lounges.
- The Clocktower is the hotel's primary restaurant; 24-hour room service is available.
- The property lists two bars/lounges for cocktails and quieter evenings.
- Cooked-to-order breakfasts are available for a surcharge (hours provided).
The EDITION is better for travelers who prefer a refined single-restaurant focus and quieter bar spaces.
Pools & signature amenity: Virgin's seasonal rooftop pool vs EDITION's offerings
Virgin Hotels New York City – Pools & signature amenity
Virgin's signature amenity is a seasonal rooftop pool deck with views and a Pool Club bar.
- Seasonal fourth-floor rooftop pool open daily in season, loungers and cabanas available.
- Pool Club bar operates alongside the pool; reservations and fees apply for loungers/cabanas after midday.
- Pool access rules: open to all ages mornings; restricted to 21+ from midday onward.
If a rooftop pool is important, Virgin delivers a clear pool-and-bar program.
The New York EDITION – Pools & signature amenity
The New York EDITION lists spa services and bars but does not publish an on-site pool in the supplier listing.
- Featured amenities highlight spa services and 2 bars/lounges and 24-hour room service.
- Listing emphasizes proximity to parks and landmarks rather than an on-site pool.
- No pool is published in the supplier details provided.
Choose The EDITION if you don't need an on-site pool and prefer hotel design and location instead.
Wellness & nightlife: Exhale Spa and rooftop nightlife vs EDITION's quiet luxury
Virgin Hotels New York City – Wellness & nightlife
Virgin combines a full Exhale Spa and 24/7 fitness with rooftop nightlife venues.
- Exhale Spa: hammam, dry sauna, snow room, salt room, 10 treatment rooms and recovery offerings; open daily.
- 24/7 fitness center with Technogym equipment and studio classes.
- Nightlife options include The Riff Raff Club and Pool Club rooftop social hours and regular happy hours.
Virgin blends wellness facilities with active evening programming and rooftop nightlife.
The New York EDITION – Wellness & nightlife
The New York EDITION offers on-site spa services and fitness facilities with a quieter nightlife profile.
- Supplier listing notes spa services on site and fitness facilities; specific spa amenity details are not published in the supplier listing.
- Two bars/lounges provide evening drinks without the same rooftop party emphasis as Virgin.
- Concierge and 24-hour front desk support event planning and restaurant reservations.
The EDITION fits travelers who want spa and fitness access without a hotel-focused nightlife scene.
Who Wins? Best Pick by Travel Style
Virgin Hotels New York City
Virgin Hotels New York City — seasonal pool deck with loungers, cabanas and a Pool Club bar.
The New York EDITION
The New York EDITION — steps from Madison Square Park and the Flatiron Building.
Virgin Hotels New York City
Virgin — multiple rooftop bars, happy hours and a 39th-floor cocktail lounge.
The New York EDITION
The New York EDITION — stylish EDITION design with an on-site signature restaurant and quieter evening spaces.
Frequently asked questions
See all FAQs →Virgin Hotels New York City vs The New York EDITION: FAQs
Which hotel is better if I want a pool?
Virgin Hotels New York City has a seasonal rooftop pool; The New York EDITION's supplier listing does not publish an on-site pool.
Are both hotels family-friendly?
Yes — both welcome families, though Virgin requires at least one person 21+ to check in and limits poolside access to 21+ after late morning.
Which is more central for Madison Square Park and Flatiron?
The New York EDITION is beside Madison Square Park and the Flatiron Building; Virgin is in nearby NoMad within an easy walk.
Do either charge a destination or mandatory fee?
Virgin Hotels New York City charges a mandatory daily Destination Fee; The New York EDITION lists a destination fee of USD 51.64 per accommodation, per night in the supplier listing.
More Virgin Hotels New York City Comparison Guides
Explore how Virgin Hotels New York City stacks up against other hotels nearby:
- Virgin Hotels New York City vs Waldorf Astoria New York
- Virgin Hotels New York City vs The St. Regis New York
- Virgin Hotels New York City vs Four Seasons Hotel New York
- Virgin Hotels New York City vs The Ritz-Carlton New York, Central Park
- Virgin Hotels New York City vs Mandarin Oriental, New York
- Virgin Hotels New York City vs The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel
- Virgin Hotels New York City vs Park Hyatt New York
- Virgin Hotels New York City vs The Pierre, A Taj Hotel, New York
- Virgin Hotels New York City vs Baccarat Hotel and Residences New York
- Virgin Hotels New York City vs The Ritz-Carlton New York, NoMad
- Virgin Hotels New York City vs The Langham, New York, Fifth Avenue
- Virgin Hotels New York City vs Lotte New York Palace
- Virgin Hotels New York City vs Trump International Hotel & Tower New York
- Virgin Hotels New York City vs JW Marriott Essex House New York
- Virgin Hotels New York City vs The Times Square EDITION
- Virgin Hotels New York City vs 1 Hotel Central Park
- Virgin Hotels New York City vs The Whitby Hotel
- Virgin Hotels New York City vs The Surrey A Corinthia Hotel
- All Virgin Hotels New York City comparisons
Book your stay
Rooftop Pool Access & Skyline Views
- Lowest rate guarantee
- Complimentary perks & upgrades
- 24/7 concierge